第六阶段:评审阶段 - 最终质量评估
阶段目标
对经过五阶段工作流处理的内容进行最终质量评估,通过多维度、多层次的审核验证,确保内容达到最高发布标准,符合所有合规要求。核心流程
🔍 全面质量评估
1.1 多维度质量检测
Copy
质量评估框架:
内容准确性评估:
- 事实核查: 100%事实准确
- 数据验证: 所有数据来源可靠
- 引用检查: 引用格式规范、来源权威
- 逻辑验证: 论证严密、结论合理
语言质量评估:
- 语法规范: 零语法错误
- 表达流畅: 语言自然流畅
- 风格统一: 全文风格一致
- 术语准确: 专业术语使用正确
结构完整性评估:
- 逻辑结构: 层次清晰、逻辑连贯
- 内容完整: 各部分内容充实
- 比例协调: 各部分篇幅合理
- 开头结尾: 开头吸引、结尾有力
价值贡献评估:
- 创新性: 观点独特、有新见解
- 实用性: 提供实用价值
- 影响力: 具有传播影响力
- 差异化: 与同类内容有明显区别
1.2 智能质量评分系统
Copy
// 内容质量评分系统
class ContentQualityScorer {
constructor(content, evaluationCriteria) {
this.content = content;
this.criteria = evaluationCriteria;
}
// 综合质量评分
async calculateOverallScore() {
const scores = {
accuracy: await this.scoreAccuracy(),
language: await this.scoreLanguage(),
structure: await this.scoreStructure(),
value: await this.scoreValue(),
engagement: await this.scoreEngagement()
};
const weights = {
accuracy: 0.3,
language: 0.2,
structure: 0.2,
value: 0.2,
engagement: 0.1
};
const overallScore = Object.entries(scores).reduce((total, [key, score]) => {
return total + (score.score * weights[key]);
}, 0);
return {
overall: Math.round(overallScore * 100) / 100,
breakdown: scores,
grade: this.determineGrade(overallScore),
recommendations: this.generateRecommendations(scores)
};
}
// 准确性评分
async scoreAccuracy() {
const factChecker = new AdvancedFactChecker();
const factCheckResults = await factChecker.checkAll(this.content);
const metrics = {
factualAccuracy: this.calculateFactualAccuracy(factCheckResults),
dataReliability: this.assessDataReliability(),
sourceCredibility: this.evaluateSourceCredibility(),
logicalConsistency: this.checkLogicalConsistency()
};
const score = Object.values(metrics).reduce((sum, metric) => sum + metric, 0) / 4;
return {
score,
metrics,
issues: factCheckResults.issues,
confidence: this.calculateAccuracyConfidence(metrics)
};
}
// 语言质量评分
async scoreLanguage() {
const languageAnalyzer = new LanguageQualityAnalyzer();
const analysis = await languageAnalyzer.analyze(this.content);
const metrics = {
grammar: 1 - (analysis.grammarErrors / analysis.totalWords),
vocabulary: analysis.vocabularyRichness,
style: analysis.styleConsistency,
readability: analysis.readabilityScore / 100,
fluency: analysis.fluencyScore
};
const score = Object.values(metrics).reduce((sum, metric) => sum + metric, 0) / 5;
return {
score,
metrics,
suggestions: analysis.suggestions,
improvements: analysis.recommendedImprovements
};
}
// 结构质量评分
async scoreStructure() {
const structureAnalyzer = new ContentStructureAnalyzer();
const structure = await structureAnalyzer.analyze(this.content);
const metrics = {
introduction: this.evaluateIntroduction(structure.introduction),
development: this.evaluateDevelopment(structure.body),
conclusion: this.evaluateConclusion(structure.conclusion),
coherence: this.assessCoherence(structure),
flow: this.evaluateFlow(structure)
};
const score = Object.values(metrics).reduce((sum, metric) => sum + metric, 0) / 5;
return {
score,
metrics,
structureMap: structure.map,
recommendations: this.getStructureRecommendations(metrics)
};
}
// 价值贡献评分
async scoreValue() {
const valueAnalyzer = new ContentValueAnalyzer();
const value = await valueAnalyzer.analyze(this.content);
const metrics = {
innovation: value.innovationScore,
usefulness: value.usefulnessScore,
uniqueness: value.uniquenessScore,
depth: value.depthScore,
impact: value.impactScore
};
const score = Object.values(metrics).reduce((sum, metric) => sum + metric, 0) / 5;
return {
score,
metrics,
valueProposition: value.proposition,
competitiveAnalysis: value.competitivePosition
};
}
// 参与度评分
async scoreEngagement() {
const engagementAnalyzer = new EngagementAnalyzer();
const engagement = await engagementAnalyzer.analyze(this.content);
const metrics = {
hook: engagement.hookStrength,
interest: engagement.interestMaintenance,
interaction: engagement.interactionPotential,
shareability: engagement.shareability,
memorability: engagement.memorabilityScore
};
const score = Object.values(metrics).reduce((sum, metric) => sum + metric, 0) / 5;
return {
score,
metrics,
engagementFactors: engagement.factors,
enhancementSuggestions: engagement.suggestions
};
}
// 确定等级
determineGrade(score) {
if (score >= 0.95) return 'A+';
if (score >= 0.90) return 'A';
if (score >= 0.85) return 'B+';
if (score >= 0.80) return 'B';
if (score >= 0.75) return 'C+';
if (score >= 0.70) return 'C';
if (score >= 0.60) return 'D';
return 'F';
}
}
⚖️ 合规性检查
2.1 多维度合规验证
Copy
合规检查体系:
内容合规:
- 版权检查: 无版权侵犯
- 引用规范: 符合引用标准
- 原创性检测: 原创度 ≥ 85%
- 敏感内容: 无违规内容
法律合规:
- 广告法合规: 无虚假宣传
- 隐私保护: 无隐私泄露
- 知识产权: 无侵权风险
- 平台规则: 符合发布平台规则
行业规范:
- 专业标准: 符合行业标准
- 伦理规范: 符合职业道德
- 技术规范: 技术表述准确
- 质量标准: 达到行业质量要求
平台政策:
- 社区准则: 符合社区规范
- 内容政策: 符合内容政策
- 发布要求: 满足发布要求
- 用户协议: 符合用户协议
2.2 自动化合规检测
Copy
// 合规性检查器
class ComplianceChecker {
constructor(content, platform) {
this.content = content;
this.platform = platform;
}
// 全面合规检查
async checkCompliance() {
const checks = {
copyright: await this.checkCopyright(),
originality: await this.checkOriginality(),
legal: await this.checkLegalCompliance(),
platform: await this.checkPlatformPolicies(),
industry: await this.checkIndustryStandards()
};
const overallCompliance = this.calculateOverallCompliance(checks);
return {
compliant: overallCompliance.score >= 0.9,
score: overallCompliance.score,
checks,
issues: overallCompliance.issues,
recommendations: overallCompliance.recommendations
};
}
// 版权检查
async checkCopyright() {
const copyrightChecker = new CopyrightChecker();
const checks = {
textOriginality: await copyrightChecker.checkTextOriginality(this.content),
imageRights: await copyrightChecker.checkImageRights(this.content),
quoteAttribution: await copyrightChecker.checkQuoteAttribution(this.content),
fairUse: await copyrightChecker.assessFairUse(this.content)
};
const issues = [];
if (checks.textOriginality.score < 0.85) {
issues.push({
type: 'potential_plagiarism',
severity: 'high',
description: '文本原创性可能不足'
});
}
return {
passed: issues.length === 0,
score: 1 - (issues.length * 0.2),
checks,
issues
};
}
// 原创性检测
async checkOriginality() {
const originalityChecker = new OriginalityChecker();
const analysis = await originalityChecker.analyze(this.content);
return {
score: analysis.originalityScore,
similarity: analysis.similarityReport,
sources: analysis.matchedSources,
recommendations: analysis.improvementSuggestions
};
}
// 法律合规检查
async checkLegalCompliance() {
const legalChecker = new LegalComplianceChecker();
const checks = {
advertising: await legalChecker.checkAdvertisingCompliance(this.content),
privacy: await legalChecker.checkPrivacyCompliance(this.content),
defamation: await legalChecker.checkDefamationRisk(this.content),
intellectualProperty: await legalChecker.checkIPCompliance(this.content)
};
const legalIssues = [];
Object.entries(checks).forEach(([area, check]) => {
if (check.risk === 'high') {
legalIssues.push({
type: area,
severity: 'high',
description: check.description
});
}
});
return {
passed: legalIssues.length === 0,
score: Math.max(0, 1 - (legalIssues.length * 0.3)),
checks,
issues: legalIssues
};
}
// 平台政策检查
async checkPlatformPolicies() {
const policyChecker = new PlatformPolicyChecker(this.platform);
const policies = await policyChecker.getRelevantPolicies();
const compliance = await Promise.all(
policies.map(policy => this.checkPolicyCompliance(policy))
);
const violations = compliance.filter(c => c.compliant === false);
return {
passed: violations.length === 0,
score: Math.max(0, 1 - (violations.length * 0.25)),
policies: compliance,
violations
};
}
// 行业标准检查
async checkIndustryStandards() {
const industryStandardsChecker = new IndustryStandardsChecker();
const standards = await industryStandardsChecker.identifyRelevantStandards(this.content);
const compliance = await Promise.all(
standards.map(standard => this.checkStandardCompliance(standard))
);
const nonCompliant = compliance.filter(c => c.meetsStandard === false);
return {
passed: nonCompliant.length === 0,
score: Math.max(0, 1 - (nonCompliant.length * 0.2)),
standards: compliance,
nonCompliant
};
}
}
👥 专家评审系统
3.1 多专家协同评审
Copy
专家评审框架:
评审专家类型:
内容专家:
- 领域知识验证
- 专业准确性评估
- 行业标准符合性
- 前沿性判断
语言专家:
- 语言质量评估
- 表达准确性检查
- 风格一致性验证
- 可读性优化建议
SEO专家:
- 搜索引擎优化评估
- 关键词策略验证
- 内容结构分析
- 传播潜力评估
法律专家:
- 法律合规性审查
- 风险评估分析
- 合规建议提供
- 预防措施建议
用户体验专家:
- 用户体验评估
- 可用性分析
- 参与度预测
- 改进建议提供
3.2 智能专家评审协调
Copy
// 专家评审协调器
class ExpertReviewCoordinator {
constructor(content, reviewRequirements) {
this.content = content;
this.requirements = reviewRequirements;
this.reviewers = [];
this.reviews = [];
}
// 初始化评审团队
async initializeReviewTeam() {
const requiredExpertise = this.identifyRequiredExpertise();
for (const expertise of requiredExpertise) {
const reviewer = await this.selectExpert(expertise);
this.reviewers.push(reviewer);
}
return this.reviewers;
}
// 识别所需专业领域
identifyRequiredExpertise() {
const contentAnalyzer = new ContentAnalyzer();
const analysis = contentAnalyzer.analyze(this.content);
const expertise = [];
if (analysis.technicalLevel === 'high') {
expertise.push('content_expert');
}
if (analysis.complexity === 'high') {
expertise.push('language_expert');
}
if (analysis.seoRequirement === 'high') {
expertise.push('seo_expert');
}
if (analysis.legalRisk === 'medium' || analysis.legalRisk === 'high') {
expertise.push('legal_expert');
}
if (analysis.userInteraction === 'high') {
expertise.push('ux_expert');
}
return expertise;
}
// 执行专家评审
async conductReviews() {
const reviewPromises = this.reviewers.map(reviewer =>
this.conductSingleReview(reviewer)
);
this.reviews = await Promise.all(reviewPromises);
return this.synthesizeReviews();
}
// 单个专家评审
async conductSingleReview(reviewer) {
const reviewFramework = this.getReviewFramework(reviewer.expertise);
const review = {
reviewer: reviewer.name,
expertise: reviewer.expertise,
timestamp: new Date(),
framework: reviewFramework,
assessment: await reviewer.review(this.content, reviewFramework),
confidence: reviewer.confidence,
recommendations: []
};
// 收集改进建议
for (const criterion of reviewFramework.criteria) {
if (review.assessment[criterion.id].score < 0.8) {
const recommendations = await reviewer.generateRecommendations(
this.content,
criterion,
review.assessment[criterion.id]
);
review.recommendations.push(...recommendations);
}
}
return review;
}
// 综合评审结果
async synthesizeReviews() {
const synthesis = {
overallScore: this.calculateOverallScore(),
consensus: this.findConsensus(),
conflicts: this.identifyConflicts(),
recommendations: this.consolidateRecommendations(),
finalDecision: this.makeFinalDecision()
};
return synthesis;
}
// 计算综合得分
calculateOverallScore() {
const scores = this.reviews.map(review =>
review.assessment.overallScore
);
const weights = this.reviews.map(review =>
this.getReviewerWeight(review.expertise)
);
const weightedScore = scores.reduce((sum, score, index) =>
sum + (score * weights[index]), 0
) / weights.reduce((sum, weight) => sum + weight, 0);
return {
score: Math.round(weightedScore * 100) / 100,
distribution: this.calculateScoreDistribution(scores),
average: scores.reduce((sum, score) => sum + score, 0) / scores.length
};
}
// 找到共识点
findConsensus() {
const consensusPoints = [];
// 分析所有评审者都同意的改进点
const allRecommendations = this.reviews.flatMap(review => review.recommendations);
const recommendationGroups = this.groupRecommendations(allRecommendations);
recommendationGroups.forEach(group => {
if (group.agreement >= 0.8) { // 80%以上同意
consensusPoints.push({
recommendation: group.recommendation,
agreement: group.agreement,
priority: this.calculatePriority(group),
supporters: group.supporters
});
}
});
return consensusPoints;
}
// 识别冲突点
identifyConflicts() {
const conflicts = [];
// 检查评分差异大的地方
const criteria = this.getAllCriteria();
criteria.forEach(criterion => {
const scores = this.reviews.map(review =>
review.assessment[criterion]?.score || 0
);
const variance = this.calculateVariance(scores);
if (variance > 0.25) { // 方差大于0.25
conflicts.push({
criterion,
scores,
variance,
reviewers: this.getReviewersForCriterion(criterion),
resolution: this.suggestConflictResolution(criterion, scores)
});
}
});
return conflicts;
}
// 整合改进建议
consolidateRecommendations() {
const allRecommendations = this.reviews.flatMap(review => review.recommendations);
const consolidated = [];
// 按重要性排序
const prioritized = allRecommendations.sort((a, b) =>
b.importance - a.importance
);
// 去重和分组
const groups = this.groupSimilarRecommendations(prioritized);
groups.forEach(group => {
if (group.recommendations.length >= 2) { // 至少2个专家同意
consolidated.push({
category: group.category,
description: group.description,
recommendations: group.recommendations,
importance: this.calculateGroupImportance(group),
effort: this.estimateImplementationEffort(group),
supporters: group.supporters
});
}
});
return consolidated;
}
// 做出最终决策
makeFinalDecision() {
const overallScore = this.calculateOverallScore().score;
const consensusCount = this.findConsensus().length;
const conflictCount = this.identifyConflicts().length;
let decision;
if (overallScore >= 0.9 && consensusCount >= 5 && conflictCount === 0) {
decision = {
status: 'APPROVED',
confidence: 'high',
message: '内容质量优秀,通过所有评审,可以发布'
};
} else if (overallScore >= 0.8 && consensusCount >= 3 && conflictCount <= 1) {
decision = {
status: 'APPROVED_WITH_MINOR_CHANGES',
confidence: 'medium',
message: '内容质量良好,进行小幅修改后可以发布'
};
} else if (overallScore >= 0.7 && consensusCount >= 2) {
decision = {
status: 'NEEDS_MODERATE_REVISION',
confidence: 'medium',
message: '内容基本达标,需要进行中等程度的修改'
};
} else {
decision = {
status: 'NEEDS_MAJOR_REVISION',
confidence: 'high',
message: '内容需要重大修改才能达到发布标准'
};
}
return decision;
}
}
📊 评审报告生成
4.1 综合评审报告
Copy
📋 最终评审报告
评审概览:
┌──────────────────────────────────────┐
│ 📅 评审日期: 2024-01-15 │
│ ⏰ 评审时间: 16:00 - 17:30 │
│ 👥 评审团队: 5位专家 │
│ 🎯 总体评分: 92/100 │
│ ✅ 评审结果: 通过 (需要轻微修改) │
└──────────────────────────────────────┘
质量评估结果:
✅ 内容准确性: 95/100 (优秀)
✅ 语言质量: 90/100 (良好)
✅ 结构完整性: 93/100 (优秀)
✅ 价值贡献: 88/100 (良好)
✅ 参与度预测: 85/100 (良好)
合规性检查结果:
✅ 版权合规: 通过 (无版权问题)
✅ 原创性检测: 92%原创 (优秀)
✅ 法律合规: 通过 (无法律风险)
✅ 平台政策: 通过 (符合所有要求)
✅ 行业标准: 通过 (达到行业标准)
专家评审结果:
🔬 内容专家: 94/100 (专业性强,数据扎实)
✍️ 语言专家: 89/100 (表达清晰,风格统一)
🔍 SEO专家: 91/100 (优化良好,传播潜力大)
⚖️ 法律专家: 96/100 (完全合规,无风险)
👤 UX专家: 87/100 (用户体验良好,可优化)
改进建议 (高优先级):
1. 增强开篇吸引力 (语言专家建议)
2. 添加更多实用案例 (内容专家建议)
3. 优化关键词分布 (SEO专家建议)
4. 简化部分复杂表述 (语言专家建议)
改进建议 (中优先级):
1. 增加互动性元素 (UX专家建议)
2. 补充数据可视化 (内容专家建议)
3. 优化段落长度 (语言专家建议)
4. 强化行动号召 (UX专家建议)
发布建议:
✅ 修改完成后即可发布
✅ 建议发布时间: 工作日上午10:00
✅ 推荐发布平台: 技术博客 + LinkedIn
✅ 配套推广: 准备3条社交媒体内容
4.2 评审报告自动生成
Copy
// 评审报告生成器
class ReviewReportGenerator {
constructor(reviewResults, contentMetadata) {
this.results = reviewResults;
this.metadata = contentMetadata;
}
// 生成完整评审报告
async generateReport() {
const report = {
overview: this.generateOverview(),
qualityAssessment: this.generateQualitySection(),
complianceCheck: this.generateComplianceSection(),
expertReviews: this.generateExpertSection(),
recommendations: this.generateRecommendationsSection(),
publicationGuidance: this.generatePublicationSection(),
summary: this.generateSummary()
};
return this.formatReport(report);
}
// 生成概览部分
generateOverview() {
return {
metadata: this.metadata,
overallScore: this.results.overallScore,
decision: this.results.finalDecision,
keyMetrics: this.extractKeyMetrics(),
timeline: this.calculateReviewTimeline()
};
}
// 生成质量评估部分
generateQualitySection() {
const quality = this.results.qualityAssessment;
return {
overallScore: quality.overall,
dimensions: {
accuracy: {
score: quality.accuracy.score,
status: this.getStatus(quality.accuracy.score),
details: quality.accuracy.metrics,
highlights: quality.accuracy.strengths,
concerns: quality.accuracy.issues
},
language: {
score: quality.language.score,
status: this.getStatus(quality.language.score),
details: quality.language.metrics,
highlights: quality.language.strengths,
concerns: quality.language.issues
},
structure: {
score: quality.structure.score,
status: this.getStatus(quality.structure.score),
details: quality.structure.metrics,
highlights: quality.structure.strengths,
concerns: quality.structure.issues
},
value: {
score: quality.value.score,
status: this.getStatus(quality.value.score),
details: quality.value.metrics,
highlights: quality.value.strengths,
concerns: quality.value.issues
},
engagement: {
score: quality.engagement.score,
status: this.getStatus(quality.engagement.score),
details: quality.engagement.metrics,
highlights: quality.engagement.strengths,
concerns: quality.engagement.issues
}
},
summary: this.generateQualitySummary(quality)
};
}
// 生成合规检查部分
generateComplianceSection() {
const compliance = this.results.complianceCheck;
return {
overallCompliance: {
compliant: compliance.compliant,
score: compliance.score,
riskLevel: this.assessRiskLevel(compliance.score)
},
checks: {
copyright: {
status: compliance.checks.copyright.passed ? 'PASS' : 'FAIL',
score: compliance.checks.copyright.score,
details: compliance.checks.copyright.checks,
issues: compliance.checks.copyright.issues
},
originality: {
score: compliance.checks.originality.score,
status: this.getOriginalityStatus(compliance.checks.originality.score),
details: compliance.checks.originality.similarity,
sources: compliance.checks.originality.sources
},
legal: {
status: compliance.checks.legal.passed ? 'PASS' : 'FAIL',
score: compliance.checks.legal.score,
details: compliance.checks.legal.checks,
risks: compliance.checks.legal.issues
},
platform: {
status: compliance.checks.platform.passed ? 'PASS' : 'FAIL',
score: compliance.checks.platform.score,
policies: compliance.checks.platform.policies,
violations: compliance.checks.platform.violations
},
industry: {
status: compliance.checks.industry.passed ? 'PASS' : 'FAIL',
score: compliance.checks.industry.score,
standards: compliance.checks.industry.standards,
gaps: compliance.checks.industry.nonCompliant
}
},
summary: this.generateComplianceSummary(compliance)
};
}
// 生成专家评审部分
generateExpertSection() {
const expert = this.results.expertReviews;
return {
overall: {
score: expert.overallScore.score,
average: expert.overallScore.average,
distribution: expert.overallScore.distribution
},
consensus: {
points: expert.consensus.map(point => ({
area: point.recommendation.category,
description: point.recommendation.description,
agreement: Math.round(point.agreement * 100) + '%',
priority: point.priority,
supporters: point.supporters
})),
count: expert.consensus.length,
coverage: this.calculateConsensusCoverage(expert.consensus)
},
conflicts: {
items: expert.conflicts.map(conflict => ({
criterion: conflict.criterion,
variance: Math.round(conflict.variance * 100) + '%',
scores: conflict.scores,
resolution: conflict.resolution
})),
count: expert.conflicts.length,
resolution: this.suggestConflictResolution(expert.conflicts)
},
reviewers: expert.reviews.map(review => ({
name: review.reviewer,
expertise: review.expertise,
score: review.assessment.overallScore,
confidence: review.confidence,
keyFindings: this.extractKeyFindings(review)
})),
summary: this.generateExpertSummary(expert)
};
}
// 生成改进建议部分
generateRecommendationsSection() {
const recommendations = this.results.expertReviews.consolidatedRecommendations;
return {
prioritized: recommendations.map(rec => ({
category: rec.category,
description: rec.description,
priority: rec.importance,
effort: rec.effort,
impact: this.estimateImpact(rec),
supporters: rec.supporters,
details: rec.recommendations
})),
summary: {
total: recommendations.length,
highPriority: recommendations.filter(r => r.importance >= 0.8).length,
mediumPriority: recommendations.filter(r => r.importance >= 0.6 && r.importance < 0.8).length,
lowPriority: recommendations.filter(r => r.importance < 0.6).length,
estimatedEffort: this.calculateTotalEffort(recommendations)
},
actionPlan: this.generateActionPlan(recommendations)
};
}
// 生成发布指导部分
generatePublicationSection() {
const decision = this.results.expertReviews.finalDecision;
return {
status: decision.status,
confidence: decision.confidence,
message: decision.message,
timeline: this.suggestPublicationTimeline(decision),
platforms: this.recommendPlatforms(),
promotion: this.suggestPromotionStrategy(),
monitoring: this.recommendMonitoringMetrics(),
nextSteps: this.generateNextSteps(decision)
};
}
// 格式化报告
formatReport(report) {
return {
header: this.generateReportHeader(),
sections: [
{ title: '评审概览', content: report.overview },
{ title: '质量评估', content: report.qualityAssessment },
{ title: '合规检查', content: report.complianceCheck },
{ title: '专家评审', content: report.expertReviews },
{ title: '改进建议', content: report.recommendations },
{ title: '发布指导', content: report.publicationGuidance }
],
summary: report.summary,
footer: this.generateReportFooter(),
metadata: {
generatedAt: new Date(),
version: '1.0',
format: 'comprehensive_review_report'
}
};
}
}
🎯 最终决策与发布指导
5.1 智能决策系统
Copy
// 最终决策系统
class FinalDecisionEngine {
constructor(evaluationResults) {
this.results = evaluationResults;
}
// 做出最终发布决策
async makeFinalDecision() {
const decisionFactors = {
quality: this.assessQuality(),
compliance: this.assessCompliance(),
expertConsensus: this.assessExpertConsensus(),
readiness: this.assessReadiness(),
risk: this.assessRisk()
};
const decisionScore = this.calculateDecisionScore(decisionFactors);
const decision = this.determineDecision(decisionScore);
return {
decision,
score: decisionScore,
factors: decisionFactors,
conditions: this.getConditions(decision),
timeline: this.suggestTimeline(decision),
confidence: this.calculateConfidence(decisionScore)
};
}
// 评估质量因素
assessQuality() {
const quality = this.results.qualityAssessment;
return {
score: quality.overall,
grade: this.determineGrade(quality.overall),
strengths: this.identifyStrengths(quality),
concerns: this.identifyConcerns(quality),
readiness: this.assessQualityReadiness(quality)
};
}
// 评估合规因素
assessCompliance() {
const compliance = this.results.complianceCheck;
return {
compliant: compliance.compliant,
score: compliance.score,
risks: this.identifyComplianceRisks(compliance),
blockers: this.identifyComplianceBlockers(compliance),
confidence: compliance.score >= 0.95 ? 'high' :
compliance.score >= 0.85 ? 'medium' : 'low'
};
}
// 评估专家共识
assessExpertConsensus() {
const expert = this.results.expertReviews;
return {
consensus: expert.consensus.length,
conflicts: expert.conflicts.length,
agreement: expert.overallScore.score >= 0.8 ? 'high' :
expert.overallScore.score >= 0.7 ? 'medium' : 'low',
diversity: this.assessExpertDiversity(expert),
confidence: this.calculateExpertConfidence(expert)
};
}
// 评估发布准备度
assessReadiness() {
const factors = {
contentReady: this.isContentReady(),
assetsReady: this.areAssetsReady(),
platformReady: this.arePlatformsReady(),
promotionReady: this.isPromotionReady()
};
return {
overall: Object.values(factors).every(f => f.ready),
factors,
gaps: this.identifyReadinessGaps(factors),
timeline: this.estimateReadinessTime(factors)
};
}
// 确定最终决策
determineDecision(score) {
if (score >= 0.95) {
return {
action: 'APPROVE_IMMEDIATE',
message: '内容质量优秀,立即批准发布',
confidence: 'very_high'
};
} else if (score >= 0.85) {
return {
action: 'APPROVE_WITH_MINOR_CHANGES',
message: '内容质量良好,小幅修改后发布',
confidence: 'high'
};
} else if (score >= 0.75) {
return {
action: 'APPROVE_WITH_MODERATE_CHANGES',
message: '内容基本达标,需要中等程度修改',
confidence: 'medium'
};
} else if (score >= 0.60) {
return {
action: 'REQUEST_MAJOR_REVISION',
message: '内容需要重大修改才能发布',
confidence: 'medium'
};
} else {
return {
action: 'REJECT',
message: '内容质量不达标,不建议发布',
confidence: 'high'
};
}
}
}
5.2 发布策略建议
Copy
发布策略系统:
决策类型映射:
APPROVE_IMMEDIATE:
立即发布:
- 时间: 当前最佳时间窗口
- 平台: 所有预定平台
- 推广: 立即启动推广计划
- 监控: 实时监控发布效果
APPROVE_WITH_MINOR_CHANGES:
快速修改后发布:
- 时间: 修改完成后24小时内
- 修改项: 优先处理高优先级建议
- 平台: 主要平台优先发布
- 推广: 基础推广启动
APPROVE_WITH_MODERATE_CHANGES:
标准修改后发布:
- 时间: 修改完成后3-7天内
- 修改项: 处理所有中高优先级建议
- 平台: 核心平台发布
- 推广: 计划性推广
REQUEST_MAJOR_REVISION:
重大修改:
- 时间: 重新评审周期
- 修改范围: 全面修订
- 平台: 暂不发布
- 推广: 重新制定推广策略
REJECT:
不发布:
- 时间: 无
- 修改: 重新创作或大幅修改
- 平台: 无
- 推广: 无
发布时机建议:
最佳时间窗口:
- 工作日: 上午9:00-11:00, 下午2:00-4:00
- 周期: 周二、周三、周四
- 避开: 周末、节假日、重大事件期间
平台特性适配:
技术博客: 深度内容最佳时间
社交媒体: 高峰时段发布
行业媒体: 编辑时间表适配
视频平台: 观看高峰期发布
📋 评审完成与交付
6.1 最终交付清单
Copy
✅ 评审完成确认清单
质量评估完成:
- [x] 内容质量评分 ≥ 85分
- [x] 所有质量维度评估完成
- [x] 质量问题识别和分析完成
- [x] 改进建议生成完成
合规性检查完成:
- [x] 版权合规检查通过
- [x] 原创性检测达标
- [x] 法律合规验证通过
- [x] 平台政策检查通过
专家评审完成:
- [x] 专家团队组建完成
- [x] 专业领域评审完成
- [x] 评审意见收集完成
- [x] 共识和冲突分析完成
评审报告完成:
- [x] 综合评审报告生成
- [x] 详细分析和建议完成
- [x] 发布策略制定完成
- [x] 风险评估和应对完成
交付物准备:
- [x] 最终版本内容
- [x] 评审报告文档
- [x] 修改建议清单
- [x] 发布指导文档
6.2 项目总结与归档
Copy
📊 项目总结报告
项目基本信息:
- 项目名称: [具体项目名称]
- 项目类型: [内容类型]
- 创建时间: [开始时间]
- 完成时间: [结束时间]
- 总耗时: [总时间]
- 参与人员: [团队成员]
六阶段工作流执行情况:
✅ 研究阶段: 需求分析与信息收集 - 100%完成
✅ 构思阶段: 内容方案设计与策略制定 - 100%完成
✅ 计划阶段: 详细执行计划制定 - 100%完成
✅ 执行阶段: 内容创作实施 - 100%完成
✅ 优化阶段: 质量提升与完善 - 100%完成
✅ 评审阶段: 最终质量评估 - 100%完成
最终成果:
- 内容质量: [最终质量评分]
- 合规状态: [合规检查结果]
- 专家评价: [专家评审结果]
- 发布建议: [发布决策]
- 预期效果: [传播预期]
关键指标:
- 原创度: [具体百分比]
- 专业准确度: [具体评分]
- 可读性指数: [具体数值]
- SEO评分: [具体分数]
- 预期传播力: [预期范围]
经验总结:
- 成功经验: [关键成功因素]
- 改进机会: [可优化环节]
- 最佳实践: [可复制经验]
- 风险防范: [风险控制措施]
后续计划:
- 发布时间表: [具体计划]
- 推广策略: [推广方案]
- 效果监测: [监测指标]
- 持续优化: [优化计划]
使用示例
Copy
# 评审阶段示例响应
⏺ [模式:评审] - 最终质量评估与合规检查
🔍 正在进行全面质量评估...
📊 质量评估结果:
- 内容准确性: 94/100 ✅
- 语言质量: 89/100 ✅
- 结构完整性: 92/100 ✅
- 价值贡献: 87/100 ✅
- 参与度预测: 85/100 ✅
总体质量评分: 89.4/100 ✅
⚖️ 合规性检查结果:
- 版权合规: 通过 ✅
- 原创性检测: 93%原创 ✅
- 法律合规: 通过 ✅
- 平台政策: 通过 ✅
- 行业标准: 通过 ✅
总体合规评分: 96/100 ✅
👥 专家评审结果:
- 内容专家: 92/100 ✅
- 语言专家: 88/100 ✅
- SEO专家: 91/100 ✅
- 法律专家: 97/100 ✅
- UX专家: 86/100 ✅
专家共识度: 89% ✅
📋 改进建议 (按优先级):
高优先级:
1. 增强开篇吸引力 (语言专家建议)
2. 优化关键词分布 (SEO专家建议)
3. 添加实用案例 (内容专家建议)
中优先级:
1. 简化复杂表述 (语言专家建议)
2. 增加互动元素 (UX专家建议)
3. 强化行动号召 (UX专家建议)
🎯 最终决策:
✅ 状态: APPROVE_WITH_MINOR_CHANGES
📊 评分: 91/100
⏱️ 时间: 修改完成后24小时内发布
🎯 置信度: 高
💬 建议: 内容质量优秀,进行小幅修改后即可发布
📅 发布时间建议:
- 最佳发布时间: 明天上午10:00
- 发布平台: 技术博客 + LinkedIn
- 配套推广: 准备3条社交媒体内容
📋 交付准备:
✅ 最终内容已优化完成
✅ 评审报告已生成
✅ 修改建议清单已准备
✅ 发布指导已制定
✅ 监控指标已设置
---
🎉 恭喜!内容已通过最终评审,达到发布标准!
项目完成状态: 100% ✅
工作流阶段: 6/6 完成 ✅
质量达标: 是 ✅
合规检查: 通过 ✅
专家认可: 是 ✅
您的内容创作项目已圆满完成!
🎉 自动化写作系统完成
通过完整的六阶段工作流,自动化写作系统为内容创作者提供了:- 系统性需求分析 - 确保创作方向的准确性
- 多元化方案设计 - 提供最优的创作策略
- 详细化执行计划 - 保证过程的高效性
- 智能化内容生成 - 实现高质量创作
- 全面化质量优化 - 提升内容价值
- 专业化质量评审 - 确保发布标准
